Comparison of OO 4-4-0 Class 4P Compound MR/LMS models

Trix OO 4-4-0 Class 4P Compound MR/LMS Hornby OO 4-4-0 Class 4P Compound MR/LMS Hornby OO 4-4-0 Class 4P Compound MR/LMS Bachmann Branchline OO 4-4-0 Class 4P Compound MR/LMS
Manufacturer Trix Hornby Hornby Bachmann Branchline
Year model introduced 1939 1981 2011 2011
DCC Capability DCC incompatible Motor fitted but no DCC socket. Ringfield motor DCC Ready. 8-pin socket DCC Ready. 21-pin socket
Bodyshell
Bodyshells represented (of Prototypes)
LMS 4P "Compound" No No No Yes
Midland Railway 1000 Class No No No Yes
Detailing
Bodyshell - factory-fitted separate details
Coal rails No No Yes
No
Handrails Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Lamp irons No No No Yes
Pipe work No No No Yes
Safety valve No Yes
Yes
Yes
Water scoop No No No Yes
Whistle No Yes
No No
Whistle - turned brass No No Yes
Yes
Chassis/underframe detail
Brake rigging chassis No Yes
No Yes
Bodyshell - separately-fitted details - in detailing pack (where applicable)
Drain cocks No No No Yes
Cab, footplate & interior detail
Detailed & painted No No No Yes
Glazing No No No Yes
Tender
Has easy-to-use coupling to loco Yes
Yes
No No
Has enclosure for speaker No No No Yes
Houses digital decoder No No Yes
Yes
Houses PCB No No Yes
Yes
Permanently coupled to locomotive No No Yes
Yes
Wheel "aesthetics"
Chemically-blackened No No Yes
Yes
Coloured-plastic No Yes
No No
Nickel-plated No Yes
No No
Painted No No No Yes
Solid-spoked wheels Yes
No No No
Traction tyres No No Yes
No
Bufferbeam detail (pre-fitted)
Cosmetic coupling - hook only No No No Yes
Now an invalid entry. Coupling info has it's own field. Cosmetic coupling slot No No Yes
No
Pipework - pre-fitted to front No No No Yes
Pipework - pre-fitted to rear No No No Yes
Sprung buffers No No Yes
Yes
Bufferbeam detail (in detailing pack)
Cosmetic coupling No No Yes
No
Detail pack also contains...
Crew No Yes
No No
Mechanical
Working cosmetic features
Smoke unit pre-fitted No Yes
No No
Chassis construction Diecast
Plastic & metal
Plastic & metal
Plastic & metal
Loco-driven wheels (number of) 4 wheels
None
2 wheels
2 wheels
Minimum radius Radius 1
Radius 2
Radius 2
Radius 2
Coupling socket/mounting
Fixed Yes
Yes
Yes
No
NEM pockets No No No Yes
Coupling type Peco style
Tension lock
Tension lock
Tension lock
Weighting (to assist adhesion)
Within chassis No No No Yes
Within tender No Yes
No No
Separating the body from the chassis Secured with one or more screws
Secured with one or more screws
No No
Electrical
Motor type 3-pole
Ringfield
5-pole (standard)
Can motor
Motor location Locomotive
Tender
Locomotive
Locomotive
Power collection No 2 rail DC
2 rail DC
2 rail DC
Pickups No Tender wheels and two Driving wheel axles
Driving wheels only
Driving wheels and tender wheels
DCC speaker No provision for speaker
No provision for speaker
No provision for speaker
Provision for a speaker (dimensions unknown)
Items in Stock View View View View

This information is maintained by our team of Product Experts. Please don’t hesitate to get in touch if you have any feedback or questions about this content.